For a man who’s enjoyed a solid five-decade membership of the British rock establishment, Billy Nicholls must be one of its least-known figures. From being engaged as a staff songwriter to Andrew Loog Oldham’s upstart Immediate Records at the tender age of eighteen, to composer of I Can’t Stop Loving You (Though I Try), the royalties from the multiple cover versions of which should assure his pension, to MD of the Who’s and Pete Townshend’s concert activities for the last thirty-odd years, Nicholls has enjoyed a fruitful but surprisingly low-profile relationship with the industry, only recently achieving acclaim as the author of one of psychedelia’s great lost gems.
The history of Would You Believe is as engaging a tale as that of Nicholls himself. When Oldham fell out with the Stones in 1967 he redirected all his resources into making the youthful Nicholls a star of the psychedelic pop scene. The results were the single Would You Believe, which hit the racks in January 1968, and the like-titled album that followed in short order. The single has been described as the most over-produced record of the sixties, and with reason; a modest psych-pop love song, it’s swathed in overblown orchestration including baroque strings, harpsichord, banjo (!), tuba (!!), and demented answer-back vocals from Steve Marriott. A trifle late for the high tide of UK psych, it failed to trouble the charts. Unfazed, Oldham and Nicholls pressed on with the album, Nicholls providing a steady stream of similarly well-crafted ditties and a bevy of top-rated London sessionmen providing the backings, thankfully with somewhat more subtlety than on the prototype cut. The album was ready for pressing just as the revelation of Oldham’s reckless financial overstretch brought about Immediate’s overnight demise, and only about a hundred copies ever made it to wax, most of which somehow surfaced in Sweden. The album became one of the mythical lost albums of the sixties, and original copies now fetch over a grand in GBP.
The record itself was heralded then, and is still often described today, as the English answer to Pet Sounds, with Nicholls’s songwriting being compared to Brian Wilson’s. This is blatant hype, and the writing certainly doesn’t get close, but the album is still the epitome of sixties Britsike, a bunch of fine acid-pop songs rendered with glorious harmonies and superb lysergic arrangements that wouldn’t have disgraced George Martin. Put it this way, if you like Ogden’s Nut Gone Flake or A Teenage Opera or even The Who Sell Out you’ll enjoy this. The sound and the production are sometimes closer to the Stones’ We Love You / Satanic Majesties output, unsurprising since it was recorded in the same studio with many of the same sessioneers, including the incomparable Nicky Hopkins on assorted keys, though this is – the title track apart – a far more taut and less self-indulgent collection than the Glimmer Twins’ psychedelic endeavours. Sundry Small Faces hung around, with Marriott contributing huge fuzz-psych guitar to Girl From New York. Indeed there’s plenty of sonic variety, from the tight structure and Townshend-style telegraph guitar of London Social Degree (go figure the acronym there, folks), through the lush Byrdsy 1string-driven (Cut And) Come Again which garnered a cover from Del Shannon, to the full-on acid rock treatments of Being Happy and It Brings me Down with its trippy false ending.
After the failure of Would You Believe Nicholls took a back seat from stardom and began a belated apprenticeship in the music industry, initially working on low-profile projects with Ronnie Lane and old acquaintance Townshend whilst gaining an understanding of all its facets that would stand him in good stead for the next forty years. He released nothing new under his own name until 1974’s Love Songs, a solid soft-rock venture that deserves a review of its own here, and may well get one. Meanwhile Would You Believe is readily available as a CD reissue, or you can get seven of its eleven songs “ plus three outtakes from the album’s sessions, which are every bit as good as those eventually used “ on Nicholls’s fine career retrospective Forever’s No Time At All.
by Len Liechti
Tracks
Disc 1
1. Would You Believe (Jeremy Paul) - 2:44
2. Come Again - 2:36
3. Life Is Short - 3:10
4. Feeling Easy - 3:15
5. Daytime Girl - 2:45
6. Daytime Girl (Coda) - 1:39
7. London Social Degree - 2:22
8. Portobello Road - 2:08
9. Question Mark - 2:29
10.Being Happy - 2:21
11.Girl From New York - 3:22
12.It Brings Me Down - 4:40
13.Would You Believe (Jeremy Paul) - 2:45
14.Daytime Girl - 2:44
15.I Want To Be Friendly With You - 1:57
16.Always On My Mind - 2:23
17.Would You Believe (Jeremy Paul) - 2:45
All compositions by Billy Nicholls except where noted
Tracks 1-17 "Would You Believe" (The Original 1968 Album)
Disc 2
1. Would You Believe (Jeremy Paul) - 2:29
2. Happiness Song - 1:51
3. Cut And Come Again - 2:21
4. Casey Jones - 0:26
5. Always On My Mind - 2:31
6. I'm To Blame (Caleb Quaye) - 3:13
7. Feeling Easy - 2:37
8. Back About Four - 2:03
9. Umbrella Song - 1:39
10.It Brings Me Down - 2:25
11.Life Is Short - 3:00
12.Haven't Any Money - 1:36
13.Good Day Goodnight - 2:14
14.The Fortune Teller - 2:19
15.London Social Degree - 2:03
16.I Want To Be Friendly With You - 1:38
17.Being Happy - 2:05
18.Love Is All Around - 2:31
19.Walking Through The Park - 2:48
20.Portobello Road - 2:13
21.The Rest Of My Life - 1:31
22.It Brings Me Down - 5:06
All compositions by Billy Nicholls except where noted
Tracks 1-22 Snapshot Demos and Outtakes 1967-68
Personnel
*Billy Nicholls - Vocals, Acoustic Guitar
*Big Jim Sullivan - Acoustic, Electric Guitars
*John Paul Jones - Bass, Backing Vocals
*Ronnie Lane - Bass, Backing Vocals
*Jerry Shirley - Drums
*Kenney Jones - Drums
*Joe Moretti - Electric Guitar
*Steve Marriott - Electric Guitar, Backing Vocals
*Nicky Hopkins - Harpsichord
*Ian McLagan - Organ
*Caleb Quaye - Electric Guitar, Piano
*Barry Husband - Backing Vocals
*Denny Gerrard - Backing Vocals
*Al Carlson - Harmonica